Friday, October 05, 2007

A powerful panel without power

Lingam tape : Gov't must be bold to get to the truth



The 3-man panel


The Special Independent Panel investigating the authenticity of the video clip allegedly detailing a conversation about judicial appointments dropped the first bombshell after its inaugural meeting, - “It has no legal power, no power to administer an oath, no power to compel witnesses to come forward and no power to commit anybody for contempt”.


Furthermore the members of the panel have no immunity under the law and their work would depend very much on the civic consciousness and co-operation of members of the public. This comes as great disappointment to Malaysians who had placed so much faith in the panel to help restore integrity to our judiciary.


It is puzzling why a panel with no legal authority should be set up in the first place.Wouldn't it be a waste of taxpayers' money? How can the panel be independent when it is instituted by the executive and answerable solely to the government? How impartial can the government be in getting to the root of the scandal when it is also partly responsible for it?


The panel is depending on the people with civic consciousness to come forward to provide information on the controversial lawyer-judge video clip.The whole issue is regarding investigation into alleged misconduct at the highest level of the judiciary. If there is lack of civic consciousness at that level, how can we expect ordinary members of the public to have such a virtue in abundance to come forward to testify.Morever even among those who possess such civic consciousness, how many would dare come forward when they are not protected against reprisals?


Somebody has taken the videos, implicating serious misconduct at the highest level of the judiciary. If the allegations are proven true, it is a very grave offense. The government must take this matter very seriously and leave no stone unturned to investigate these allegations with great urgency.It should be bold enough to take whatever action necessary, including setting up a Royal Commission of Inquiry, to clear the judiciary of any wrongdoings.It should give top priority to safeguard the integrity in the judiciary.The primary concern should be the truth or otherwise of the allegations in the video, the motive for its release is secondary.


There are 2 aspects to the tape scandal; the authenticity of the tape and the truth of the allegations contained in it. Both these aspects should be probed so that we can get down to the truth. If the video is found to be unauthentic then action must be taken against whoever produced it with evil intent.

Irrespective of whether the video is genuine or otherwise, it has highlighted the need for a comprehensive review of the procedures for the promotion of judges in the country.

We are often told that justice must not only be done but it must also be seen to be done. Similarly the judiciary must be seen to be clean and independent in the eyes of the rakyat.Otherwise the very purpose of existence of the institution would be questionable.

Dr.Chris Anthony

No comments:

CNY - Year of the dragon

Happy Chinese New Year to all, in particular the Chinese members of our bigger Malaysian family.May this Year of the Dragon bring peace &...